Review | Bright Cellars Wine Subscription Box


Look, I’m going to level with you. I LOVE wine. I’ve known about Bright Cellars for months and months and hadn’t allowed myself to subscribe, but when I got an offer for 50% off my first shipment, I just couldn’t resist! 

Bright Cellars is a wine club, but it’s not your run-of-the-mill wine club. It’s specially curated just for you and your palette! When you sign up, you complete a 7-question taste evaluation – an algorithm that breaks down your taste preferences. You can also select whether you’d prefer whites, reds, or a combination of the two. Then, they select 4 wines that they think you’ll love! Here’s a peek at a few of the quiz questions:

Click to try it for yourself!

Click to try it for yourself!

I felt like my wine matches were spot on! Once you’ve completed the quiz and placed your order, you’re assigned a wine concierge. This will be the person who assures that you have a great experience, they’re your go-to person for any questions or comments, and they’re willing to just chat with you about wine! My concierge (Maria) is very friendly and I quickly received an email from her introducing herself, which was a very nice touch.

Shipping is FAST. I placed my order on Tuesday night around 7 PM and woke up this morning (Saturday) to a big ol’ box of wine in my kitchen. It was packaged so that the bottles were very secure and I love that they individually wrap each bottle and hold the tissue together with adorable wine quote stickers!


My favorite sticker reads, “Spilling wine is the adult version of letting go of your balloon.”

Once you’ve received your shipment and tried the wines, you’re able to sign into the Bright Cellars website and rate each bottle. The idea is that as time goes on, they’ll learn more about your taste preferences and be able to send the perfect wine your way. Pretty cool, huh?


My October shipment!

I think that what Bright Cellars is doing is pretty genius and I’m excited to try my new vino! Here’s a breakdown of my experience with them thus far…


  1. It’s a curated experience just for you and your tastebuds!
  2. Their website is easy to use and navigate.
  3. From what I’ve seen so far, they have a very friendly, helpful staff.
  4. Wine is packaged with care and shipped fast.
  5. You’re able to rate wine for better future matches.
  6. “Delight Guarantee” – If you’re sent a bottle that you don’t love, your wine concierge will help you select a free replacement bottle for the next month.
  7. Their branding is cute!
  8. You can skip a month or cancel at any time. (I LOVE when skipping a month is an option.)
  9. They have a rewards system in place that allows you to earn extra bottles for referring friends!


  1. While on the one hand, I appreciate the effort to save trees (if that’s why), I have to say, I didn’t love that there was nothing in the box besides wine. In my previous experience with wine clubs, I’ve always gotten tasting notes with the shipment, which I really loved. It’s fun to look over the notes and read about the wine while you’re tasting. To be fair, Bright Cellars does offer this information on their website, but I’d personally prefer a notecard.

I feel that the price is more of a neutral for my budget than a pro or con. Each monthly shipment of 4 bottles is $60 + $8 shipping. $68/4= $17/bottle, which is about how much I typically spend on a bottle at the store, give or take a few bucks. While I’d love to see the price come down a bit, I do feel that it’s reasonable for the experience you’re getting, especially considering they have a “delight guarantee” and an opportunity to earn extra bottles.

As I mentioned before, I received this shipment for 50% off – totaling $38 with shipping, which works out to $9.50/bottle. Now that’s a price I can get down with!

And guess what? I have good news for you – you can get your first shipment for 50% off too by using this link! Give it a shot and let me know what you think.


xx, JoAnna

bcBadgeGoP.S. They’re a fairly new company, so show them some social media love and follow them on Facebook and Twitter!

18 thoughts on “Review | Bright Cellars Wine Subscription Box

      • I’m not sure! I asked Maria, my wine concierge, if she could provide a list of the states that they do not ship to, but she let me know that a lot of alcohol laws are always changing so they were anticipating that their shipment capabilities would continue to change, too. I do know that if you TRY to sign up and they can’t ship to your state, it doesn’t let you finish the onboarding process. So, I’d recommend giving it a shot and the worst that will happen is that you’ll waste 10 minutes and get your hopes up. Sorry I couldn’t be more helpful!


    • It’s automatically renewed every month on the date you sign up. You can cancel at any time and there are no cancellation fees (that I am aware of, but I will double-check with Maria). You can also skip months whenever you need to, which is awesome! What state are you in, if you don’t mind me asking? There are some states that they can’t ship to because of liquor laws so I can check for you, if you want.

      Also– just want to throw this out there because it blew my mind: they process on the day of the month you sign up, but I wanted mine in time for Thanksgiving this month and they processed it for me early! I thought that was so nice. 🙂


  1. Pingback: Review | Bright Cellars Wine Subscription Box [Nov ’14] | Thrifting & Bitching

  2. Pingback: Oscars Night! | A Viewing Party | Thrifting & Bitching

  3. Pingback: This Bright Cellars Shipment = THIRTEEN Bottles of Wine | Thrifting & Bitching

  4. I had a horrible experience with them and yes I live in PA It took 2wks for me to get my order and when I did I only received 3 bottles because one broke during delivery and they didn’t even send me a replacement and when I tried to cancel my subscription they keep sending me requests to fulfill my next order ……I never did get my last bottle and what I did get was so nasty and god awefull I couldn’t even drink it…..I didn’t even use it for cooking…..I hope you have a better experience than me…GOOD LUCK


    • Oh no! That’s really unfortunate. 😦 I’ve been a member for quite a few months now and have had a great experience so far. I hope that you find another sub that you like a lot better!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s